The Hawker Squawker
The art of writing is the art of discovering what you believe. -- Gustave Flaubert
Dragonlance - the movie [Permalink]
Yesterday, the Dragonlance movie was released. I went to my local redbox and picked up a copy. For those who have never read the Dragonlance novels, you really should. It's one of the cornerstone series of fantasy literature. I even got my wife to read the books and quite surprising to her, she loved them.

How does the movie stack up? Let's start with the good points. The soundtrack was very well done and added quite a bit to the show. The voice talents include Lucy Lawless and Kiefer Sutherland. It's an hour and a half and does tell all the major plot points of the original story.

BUT. . . It gave me a headache to watch. Literally. The movie is animated, not live action, and the animation was "blurry". You could see double-lines and digital artifacts everywhere - as if whoever rendered the video had put it on a medium quality setting for some reason (my guess is to save space; the entire movie just fits on a single layer DVD, which would mean production costs would be cheaper). Even if the animation had been sharp, the quality of the animation compares to that of your average saturday morning cartoon. Again, i could live with that if the storyline were good enough. But that brings up the final point. All of the depth that made the books so good was completely lacking in the show. It was as if someone had written some cliffs notes on the book and then written the screenplay from that. It basically was like watching a book report. "The characters did this, then went here, this happened, etc ... etc..". The movie didn't draw you in, you didn't feel for the characters, the dialog was flat, and you really didn't get a sense of the epic scope that comes across in the books.

I really wanted to like this movie, but i'm afraid i can't recommend it to anyone. Thumbs DOWN. Fortunately i only paid a dollar to rent it instead of $18 to actually buy it.

Posted by shawker on Wednesday, 16 January 2008
Tags:
Comment by Dave at Wed, 16 Jan 9:21 AM
Bummer. I had such high hopes for the movie, but when I saw the trailer a couple months ago, I adjusted my expectations down. Glad I did. Still, for $1 I'll go get it at the redbox.
Comment by Luann at Wed, 16 Jan 10:50 AM
Sorry, but I have to agree. It stunk. Even the voice performances by the big names were disappointing. It's too bad because it could have been good.
Comment by Brenda at Wed, 16 Jan 12:15 PM
How could Jack Bauer let us down like that?! And to think I was considering him for a presidential write-in!!! Thanks for the "good book" suggestion... I am always looking for good books to read, and I LOVE fantasy. Gabriel just read Spiderwick in prep for the upcoming movie and I am cruising along--reading a book a night, which is amazing for a slow reader like me. I am also re-reading Narnia in prep for the May release of Prince Caspian... After the end of Harry Potter, I am thirsty for more great books. But I already know the movies are all gonna suck in comparison :)
Enter Comment

All comments are moderated

Your comment:


(not displayed)



 
 
 

Live Comment Preview: